Which of the following were among the suggested reasons for why the English should colonize the New World?

This 1884 engraving by Thomas Gold depicts a Puritan couple walking to church in the snow. The bravery and initiative of the Puritans served as a source of inspiration for colonists during the Revolutionary War. Later, the framers of the Constitution would look to the Puritan era in history for guidance when crafting the First Amendment rights for freedom of religion.

The bravery and initiative of the Puritans served as a source of inspiration for colonists during the Revolutionary War. Later, the framers of the Constitution would look to the Puritan era in history for guidance when crafting the First Amendment rights for freedom of religion.

Puritans thought civil authorities should enforce religion

The term Puritan is commonly applied to a reform movement that strove to purify the practices and structure of the Church of England in the sixteenth through eighteenth centuries. As dissidents, they sought religious freedom and economic opportunities in distant lands. They were religious people with a strong piety and a desire to establish a holy commonwealth of people who would carry out God’s will on earth. In such a commonwealth, they felt, it was the duty of the civil authorities to enforce the laws of religion, thus holding a view almost the opposite of that expressed in the First Amendment.

Puritans tried to purify the established Church of England

The strength of the Roman Catholic Church made religion and government inseparable in portions of Europe during the Middle Ages, but Martin Luther challenged this hegemony in Germany when he nailed his ninety-five theses to a church door in 1517, and the Church eventually split along Catholic and Protestant lines. The English Reformation took shape in 1529 after the pope refused King Henry VIII’s request for a divorce. The king’s anger at the pope led him to split with the Roman Catholic Church and establish the Church of England, or the Anglican Church.

By the mid-sixteenth century, some reformers thought that Protestant denominations had not gone far enough in “purifying” the church and taking it back to its New Testament roots. Puritans were among those intent on purifying the established Church of England.

Puritans had a theocratic society

Many colonists came to America from England to escape religious persecution during the reign of King James I (r. 1603–1625) and of Charles I (r. 1625–1649), James’s son and successor, both of whom were hostile to the Puritans. As the immigrants’ numbers increased, they spread out across what is now Massachusetts and New Hampshire. The Puritans formally established the Massachusetts Bay Company, which operated under royal charter. The continued immigration of colonists to New England served to multiply the number of religious denominations, which led to increased conflict.

The fact that the Puritans had left England to escape religious persecution did not mean that they believed in religious tolerance. Their society was a theocracy that governed every aspect of their lives. Freedom of religion and freedom of speech or of the press were as foreign to the Puritans as to the Church of England. When other colonists arrived with differing beliefs, they were driven out by the Puritans. For instance, the minister Roger Williams, the founder of what became Rhode Island, fled Massachusetts after his proposal to separate church and state met with Puritan hostility.

The framers of the Constitution thought that one way of avoiding the religious intolerance of the Puritan era was to encourage a multiplicity of denominations; the First Amendment specifically prohibits the kind of national religious establishment that had once dominated colonies such as Massachusetts.

This article was originally published in 2009. Daniel Baracskay teaches in the public administration program at Valdosta State University.

Send Feedback on this article

SEE ALSO

• Anne Hutchinson
• Established Churches in Early America
• James Madison
• John Winthrop
• Roger Williams
• Roman Catholics

FURTHER READING

• Dillon, Francis. The Pilgrims. Garden City, N.Y.: Doubleday, 1975.

• Dunn, Richard S. Puritans and Yankees: The Winthrop Dynasty of New England, 1630–1717. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press, 1962.

• Jones, Howard Mumford. O Strange New World: American Culture, The Formative Years. New York: Viking, 1964.

• Morgan, Edmund S. The Founding of Massachusetts: Historians and the Sources. Indianapolis, Ind.: Bobbs-Merrill, 1964.

• Morison, Samuel Eliot. Of Plymouth Plantation, 1620–1647. New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1952.

• ———. The Story of the ‘Old Colony’ of New Plymouth, 1620–1692. New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1957.

• Rourke, Constance. The Roots of American Culture, and Other Essays. New York: Harcourt, Brace, and Company, 1942.

• Wertenbaker, Thomas Jefferson. The Puritan Oligarchy: The Founding of American Civilization. New York: Grosset and Dunlap, 1947.

• Davis, Kenneth C. "America’s True History of Religious Tolerance." Smithsonian.com, Oct. 2010.

• Barry, John M. "A Puritan's 'war against religion'." Los Angeles Times, Feb 5. 2012.

Categories

Interested in First Amendment current events?

What was the reason for English colonization?

How the English became interested in the New World and started establishing colonies?

What was the main lure for emigrants from England to the New World?

Which of the following best explains why New England experienced a high rate of natural increase in the 1600s?